In this captivating article, we’re going head-to-head: Full-Face Snorkel Mask vs. Old Style Snorkel Mask. The video compares these two types of snorkel masks across various categories and evaluates the pros and cons of each. The author personally recommends using a traditional mask and snorkel, especially for beginners, as they are deemed safer and more reliable. They also discuss the comfort and reliability of both masks, comparing aspects such as water leakage, fogging, strap comfort, and potential failures. The article also dives into the utility and usefulness of each mask, highlighting that full-face snorkel masks are designed only for surface snorkeling, while traditional masks and snorkels can be used for snorkeling, scuba diving, and free diving. Safety concerns, price comparison, and the coolness factor are explored as well. Ultimately, the author concludes that the traditional mask and snorkel is the winner in terms of safety, reliability, utility, and image, although full-face snorkel masks can be beneficial for individuals with physical limitations. The article encourages viewers to share their preferences and engage in the discussion. So, which mask do you prefer?
This image is property of i.ytimg.com.
Comfort
Advantages of Full Face Snorkel Masks
Full face snorkel masks offer a number of advantages when it comes to comfort. One of the main advantages is that these masks keep all the water off your face, including your lips. This means that your lips won’t dry out from saltwater exposure, and you won’t have to worry about water seeping into your mouth. Additionally, unlike traditional masks and snorkels, full face snorkel masks don’t have anything stuck inside your mouth, which eliminates jaw fatigue from biting down on a mouthpiece. This makes them incredibly comfortable to use for extended periods of time.
Moreover, the straps on full face snorkel masks are designed to be comfortable. Many of them are made from stretchy cloth material, which provides a snug fit without causing discomfort. This material, however, may not hold up well in the long run. One of the biggest advantages of full face snorkel masks when it comes to comfort is that they never fog up. The design of the masks ensures that as you breathe in, the new air passes across the glass, preventing fogging. This eliminates the annoyance of constantly dealing with a fogged-up mask while snorkeling.
Disadvantages of Traditional Masks and Snorkels
While traditional masks and snorkels are widely used, they do come with some discomforts. One of the main disadvantages of traditional masks is that you have to bite down on a mouthpiece, which can tire out your jaw over time. For those who spend long hours snorkeling, this jaw fatigue can be quite bothersome. Additionally, traditional masks are prone to leaks, and having saltwater sit around the nose or inside the edge of the mask can become uncomfortable after a while. Furthermore, the silicone straps on traditional masks can pull on hair, which can be annoying, especially for people with long hair. These discomforts can affect overall comfort and enjoyment while snorkeling.
Reliability
Concerns with Full Face Snorkel Masks
When it comes to reliability, there are a few concerns with full face snorkel masks. One major concern is the number of parts involved in the mask’s design. There is a ball stop in the snorkel, a water drain valve at the bottom, and four one-way valves inside the mask that direct airflow. If any of these parts fail, it can potentially put the user in a dangerous or life-threatening situation. Failure of the one-way valves can result in the rebreathing of one’s own exhaled air, leading to oxygen depletion and potential unconsciousness. Additionally, the viewing window on full face snorkel masks is prone to scratching, which can affect visibility. Furthermore, the strap material on these masks, although comfortable, may stretch out and fail over time, rendering the mask ineffective.
Advantages of Traditional Masks and Snorkels
Traditional masks and snorkels have a clear advantage when it comes to reliability. One major advantage is that the snorkel and mask are separate pieces. If the snorkel fails or gets lost, the mask can still be used independently. This provides a level of security and peace of mind for snorkelers. Additionally, the smaller lens size and material used in traditional masks make them less prone to scratching, ensuring clear visibility for longer. Moreover, the design of traditional masks and snorkels is much simpler, with fewer parts that can potentially fail. This simplicity enhances their overall reliability, as there are fewer components to worry about malfunctioning.
Utility and Usefulness
Limitations of Full Face Snorkel Masks
One of the main limitations of full face snorkel masks is their limited utility. These masks are designed primarily for surface snorkeling and are not suitable for diving down to significant depths. While it is possible to dive down a few feet with a full face mask, it quickly becomes uncomfortable due to the design. The one-way valves in the mask prevent equalizing the pressure inside the mask, leading to discomfort and difficulty in diving down. Additionally, the buoyancy of the mask can make it challenging to dive deeper. Consequently, full face snorkel masks are best suited for surface snorkeling rather than more advanced water activities.
Versatility of Traditional Masks and Snorkels
In contrast, traditional masks and snorkels offer versatility in their use. They can be used for snorkeling, scuba diving, and free diving. The design of traditional masks allows for easy equalization, making it comfortable for divers to explore underwater. Moreover, traditional masks and snorkels are compact and easy to store or travel with, adding to their overall usefulness. This versatility makes traditional masks and snorkels a preferred choice for snorkelers who want to explore different water activities beyond surface snorkeling.
Safety
Safety Concerns with Full Face Snorkel Masks
There are several safety concerns associated with full face snorkel masks. One of the primary concerns is the risk of water leaking into the mask if it is not fitted properly. This can be potentially dangerous, especially for inexperienced snorkelers who may panic when water starts entering the mask. Another significant safety concern associated with full face snorkel masks is the potential for rebreathing one’s own exhaled air. As mentioned earlier, if any of the one-way valves fail, it can lead to a build-up of carbon dioxide and a decrease in oxygen levels, potentially causing unconsciousness. Additionally, in emergency situations, full face snorkel masks can be more challenging to remove quickly, which may delay escape or response time.
Advantages of Traditional Masks and Snorkels
Traditional masks and snorkels offer clear advantages when it comes to safety. Unlike full face snorkel masks, traditional masks allow snorkelers to easily clear water from the snorkel or spit it out if necessary. This quick and simple action can help prevent water inhalation and ensure the safety of the snorkeler. Additionally, traditional masks and snorkels are designed for ease of use and quick removal, making them ideal in emergency situations. The simplicity of their design allows for efficient response times, while also reducing the risk of rebreathing one’s exhaled air. The safety features of traditional masks and snorkels make them a reliable choice for individuals prioritizing their safety while snorkeling.
Price
Cost of Full Face Snorkel Masks
When it comes to price, full face snorkel masks are relatively affordable. They can typically be found starting at around $29 online, making them accessible to a wide range of individuals. The affordability of full face snorkel masks may make them an attractive option for those on a tighter budget or for snorkelers who are just starting out and want a more cost-effective option.
Cost of Traditional Masks and Snorkels
Traditional masks and snorkels are also reasonably priced, with starting prices around $25. While the prices may be slightly lower compared to full face snorkel masks, the difference is minimal. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and which type of mask and snorkel align better with the individual’s needs and snorkeling goals.
Coolness Factor
Perception of Full Face Snorkel Masks
Full face snorkel masks have gained popularity and are perceived as a modern and innovative option. They offer a different look and feel compared to traditional masks and snorkels, which can be appealing to some snorkelers. The unique design may be seen as trendy and cutting-edge, attracting individuals who want to try out the latest snorkeling gear. However, it’s important to note that perception alone should not be the sole factor in choosing a snorkeling mask. Safety, reliability, and comfort should always be taken into consideration.
Perception of Traditional Masks and Snorkels
Traditional masks and snorkels have a well-established reputation among experienced snorkelers and are widely accepted by snorkel tour operators. Their familiarity and proven reliability make them a preferred choice for many snorkelers who prioritize functionality and safety over trends. Traditional masks and snorkels are seen as the classic and reliable option, making them a popular choice among seasoned snorkel enthusiasts.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while full face snorkel masks have gained popularity, they come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. The comfort provided by full face snorkel masks, such as keeping water off the face and lips and eliminating jaw fatigue from biting down on a mouthpiece, can be appealing to some snorkelers. However, concerns about the reliability of full face snorkel masks, including the number of parts that can potentially fail, make traditional masks and snorkels the safer and more reliable option.
Traditional masks and snorkels offer versatility in their use, allowing snorkelers to explore various water activities beyond surface snorkeling. Their simplicity and ease of use enhance their overall reliability. Additionally, traditional masks and snorkels prioritize safety, with features that allow for quick water clearance and easy removal in emergency situations.
Both full face snorkel masks and traditional masks and snorkels are reasonably priced, with slight variations in cost. Ultimately, the decision between the two depends on the individual’s preferences and priorities. While full face snorkel masks may be perceived as trendy and cool, it’s crucial to consider factors such as safety, reliability, and comfort before making a choice.
In conclusion, the traditional mask and snorkel remain the winner in terms of safety, reliability, utility, and image. However, full face snorkel masks can be helpful for individuals with physical limitations or those who prefer the unique design and comfort they provide. It is recommended to prioritize personal preferences, safety, and reliability when selecting a snorkeling mask to ensure an enjoyable and secure snorkeling experience.